Black Friday / Cyber Monday Sale: get all my Itch stuff for $5.75!

June 14, 2025

How I Prep, Part One: Pre-Campaigning

Weird Writer put out a blog challenge to jumpstart discussions about how different referees prep games. This is my contribution, or rather the first part of it.

In search of the elusive Minimum Viable Play (MVP)

I’m spinning off of the idea of the Minimum Viable Product (MVP), a business term defined as:

…a version of a product with just enough features to be usable by early customers who can then provide feedback for future product development.

I replaced product with play and game, and customers with players to end up with this:

Minimum Viable Play: a version of a game with just enough features to be usable by early players who can then provide feedback for future game development.

My goal, whether I’m at the campaign level or the session level, is to prep as close to that MVP as I can get away with.

Pre-Campaign prep

Before I can prep a campaign, I need a campaign to prep for. Getting a campaign requires, in some order, finding a group of players, and determining what the campaign will be.

Decide what to play

If I have players already, we can brainstorm the campaign together. If not, I need to decide what the campaign will be and then try to sell that to perspective players.

It goes without saying that I have to have a campaign idea that excites me enough to want to run it. If I want to run a campaign but have no idea what to run, I’ve got to figure that out. I don’t know that I’ve got any methods for this part of it, other than watching, reading, and listening to various genre media to inspire ideas.

Write the campaign pitch

Once I’ve got that idea, I’ve got to render it into a form I can easily communicate. For that purpose, the MVP is the campaign pitch.

The campaign pitch is a short pithy statement or two that conveys the most vital information about the campaign. It should provide, very broadly, ideas of:

  • genre
  • setting
  • tone
  • theme
  • identity
  • activity

In other words: in some sort of world, who the players are will be doing some kind of what, in a certain style with a certain sense.

The Hollywood trick of referencing known cultural touchstones to quickly convey an idea works great here. This campaign will be Aliens meets Game of Thrones, it’s Tolkien in Outer Space, or you’re Sherlock Holmes in The Odyssey, etc.

I want to produce an evocative image that speaks to the most important elements of the game that I can easily say or, more likely these days, post to LFG spaces.

I’ve gotten fairly good at this bit but it can take some practice and you can always tweak it as you get feedback, answer questions, and talk about it. The hardest part is what comes next which is: doing nothing.

The waiting game

This is the part that I struggle with, though I’ve gotten better at it. Until I’ve got a set of commitments from players to play in this campaign, I don’t want to invest time and build up my own excitement and expectations for a campaign that might not happen.

I don’t actively avoid thinking about it. I use physical and digital notecards to jot down ideas. What I try not to do is start developing things and putting in work that might not ever pay off and that might actually be counter-productive even if the campaign does get off the ground.

I’ll try to talk more about this in the next part but I think it is key to illicit some input from players that do commit. Any work I put in before that might not jibe with that input. More than that, if I become committed to that work, I am less flexible and open to that input. In my experience, that spells trouble, so I try to avoid it as much as I can.

Know when to hold, fold, and walk away

As much as possible, I stick to that idea of the MVP. Once I’ve got a pitch, and I’ve dangled it out in front of folks, I just have to wait and hope that I get enough nibbles at it to move onto the next phase.

If I don’t, then I either need to reformulate my pitch or put the whole thing on ice. The latter option can be a very bitter pill to swallow but, sometimes, the players for the campaign I want to play just aren’t out there, or I can’t find them. Either way, the less investment I’ve sunk into it, the easier I can let it go. Not forever, maybe— I’ll keep my notes and my pitch— but for now.

If I have gotten enough folks to commit, I can move onto to the next phase of prep, which will occupy its own post, the campaign!

Have questions or comments or just want to talk? Head over to the forums or the Discord to join the conversations or start a conversation of your own!
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram