Ditch the dungeon in your next D&D game?
Can you ditch the dungeon and still play an old school D&D game? Whether it's OD&D, B/X, BECMI, or one of their clones, like Old School Essentials and Swords & Wizardry, dungeons are not a pre-requisite for having amazing adventures in fantastic worlds!
Transcript
I came across a conversation in one of the OSR spheres in which somebody asked if it would be possible to run Old School Essentials or another B/X, OD&D, old school D&D-type game essentially without the dungeons. It spawned some interesting conversation, but I thought a lot of people got in the weeds and were acting as if you couldn't possibly run these things without dungeons. I just thought, “No, stop doing this. Don't tell people that they must run a dungeon crawl—otherwise something's missing. Stop that.”
So to answer the question—if you can't guess my answer already—of course you can run these things while minimizing dungeons.
Your game doesn't need dungeons.
I've run games like that. I didn't set them up purposefully to be light on dungeons, but it's happened that way. As the game evolves over time, sometimes interests just move away from dungeons. Sometimes the interest isn't really there to begin with. In the OD&D/Chainmail game that I play in, we do very little dungeon crawling. It comes up, we enjoy doing it when we do it, but we enjoy doing a lot of other stuff that doesn’t happen to encompass dungeons.
These old games, or old style games, or rules-light games maybe—I'm not sure—but let's just stick with old style games in the vein of BX and OD&D in particular… they are extraordinarily flexible. There's really not a lot that you can't do with them. You merely have to look at a few key areas and see how you need to tweak them to get the experience that you want.
Games are flexible-- tweak the mechanics to make it the game that you want to play
If you wish to play a game that is not dependent upon dungeon crawling, all you need to do is look at the rules and look at the mechanisms, and see which ones of those—if any—are dependent on dungeon crawling, and then adjust them.
In the case of a game like BX, we know that experience points by the book comes from loot. I'm not sure if it's implied or if it's explicit, but usually most folks, myself included, rule it as loot from dangerous places, i.e., dungeons. You go into dungeons, get loot, you get out, and that is where the vast majority of your experience points comes from.
So if we were going to take BX and we were going to say, “You know what, maybe we’ll go into a tomb here or there, maybe we’ll have some lairs or little mini dungeons we’re going to get into, but dungeons aren't going to be the mainstay of our gameplay,” then we have to consider where is the loot coming from? Because that is the big engine for gathering experience points.
Change the sources of Experience Points
And we have a couple of options there. One, we can just change what you’re getting experience points from. Maybe you’re not going to get experience points from loot. Maybe you’re going to get experience points from winning battles, having successful tournaments, learning or casting particular rituals, or finding things. “Oh, you found Excalibur—great, that's a million experience points. Bravo. Well done.” Or meeting certain great individuals: “Oh, you got an audience with King Uther? Well, that's worth a bunch of points.” Maybe you want to make it more exploration-based: “Hey, if you can open up a new path across this really dangerous area that’s good for trades, great—you can do that.”
Maybe more domain-type stuff: “Okay, we’re going to give you early on some kind of manor house or castle, and if you can maintain that, then that income that's generated becomes experience points. And our game will revolve around dealing with those challenges.” Sometimes you'll have to leave your castle and foray to stop some great evil. Sometimes you might be dealing with things more locally. Sometimes you might be dealing with fellow noble folk of different rank—maybe some junior to you, your equals, your superiors—and we can feed all of that into some XP chart, table, what have you, list, and then you can get levels that way.
Change how you find Experience Point sources
Another option is to just move where the loot is. Okay, so normally we’re talking about loot from dangerous places, but what if we instead say that it’s loot in the forms of gifts, prizes, war booty, etc.—that all counts. So then instead of looking for dungeons as a way to get loot, you might be looking for, “Oh look, that tournament offers a prize of the Maltese Falcon. Okay, if I can win and get the Maltese Falcon, that'll give me a thousand XP,” or, you know, a thousand gold piece value, whatever it is that translates into XP.
“Hey, by the way, if I steal the Maltese Falcon, I might get the same amount of experience points. Also great!” Or earning favors from lords and ladies and nobles and wizards and all that kind of stuff. Great. “If I help out the Druid Circle, I'll earn some kind of pat on the back, but that pat on the back actually has an experience point value, kind of like loot.” Players can be given prizes or equipment or all this kind of stuff that can also translate into experience points.
Once you've done that, there’s really nothing else about dungeons that makes it supremely important to run in your BX game. It's just that that’s where the loot is. So you can either change where the loot is or change what is the source of XP. But just changing one of those, and suddenly you might look and say, “Wow, there's a whole other game here of things we can do.”
The two poles of original D&D were dungeons and geopolitics
And lest we forget, back in the genesis of D&D—really pre-D&D—there was originally Arneson’s game and, of course, shortly after that, Gygax’s game. They both focused on different sorts of gameplay. Yes, they both had dungeons; Gygax’s game focused very heavily on dungeons, whereas Arneson’s game focused at least as much on the geopolitics. So from the very beginning, there’s been this aspect that’s about getting into the world and getting involved in all those events and also in dungeon crawling. And you could mix and match those to whatever degree you want.
Make the game what you want!
So don’t let anyone tell you, “You must dungeon crawl. If you don’t dungeon crawl your game won’t work,” or, “You can’t—the game won’t function,” or, “You can’t play the game if you don’t dungeon crawl,” or if somebody says, “You can’t play the game if you only dungeon crawl.” You can play the game however you like. It is yours. Do with it what you will. Just understand the things that you might need to tweak to make the game you want happen.
In this case, the one thing that really hinges on dungeon crawling by the book, conventionally speaking, is that loot, which becomes XP. So we need to just adjust where that loot is coming from or where that XP is coming from—or you could do both, some combination—and we can get a perfectly serviceable and, I would say, even fun game without having the dungeons.
And having played those games—having run games that evolved into essentially being minimally dungeon-based—they can be a lot of fun. There are a lot of rewards there. Don’t let anybody say you can’t do it. Just read through, work out: “Hey, if I want to do this, I need to fix or change or adjust these couple of things.” Being that there aren’t a bunch of rules and a lot of mechanics, but there is kind of this solid chassis—I think that's why BX has had this… it’s been too long to call it a revival at this point, but that's why it has had this enduring popularity (and OD&D as well)—because they have very solid chassis. It's easy to tear down the stuff you don't want, and it's easy to put on the stuff you have, and you know that you have this base that essentially works, and you can do a lot of fiddling with different bits and it'll still work, it will still run, it will still be a fun experience.
So go ahead and throw the dungeon out of your game, or throw the world out of your dungeon. Either way, you will have a good game if you believe in yourself. Get a bunch of players who feel likewise. Make the game your own.
And that's all I’ve got. Game on. Talk to you later. Bye now.








